Sophia Kibler

Fueled by male validation and putting other women down, the pick-me girl loves eating pizza and playing video games. She doesn’t care about makeup and all those traditionally girly things. She watches football and gets down with the guys. She prides herself on being different from other girls, but she doesn’t realize how badly she’s hurting herself.

In recent years, many people, including myself, have criticized this archetype of girls in the name of female empowerment. Being a pick-me girl entails centering the male idea of what’s acceptable for women to do, which is largely regressive and harmful. Though it has to be understood that this type of behavior is not innate. The pick-me girl does not exist in a vacuum, and therefore can’t be criticized properly without acknowledging the context as to why they behave the way that they do.

Originally derived from the Grey’s Anatomy scene in which a woman declares, “Pick me. Choose me. Love me,” to a man she is seeing, Twitter users in 2016 coined the term pick-me to refer to women who seek male validation by putting down other women and femininity. Most teens today likely became familiar with the term after 2020 when it gained traction on TikTok, where creators made parodies criticizing pick-me behavior. These short-form videos gained so much popularity among women and girls because they put a name to a type of behavior that wasn’t otherwise talked about. Discussion about male validation, attitudes regarding girly interests, and what it means to be authentic started to arise. Though the internet is not particularly known for being home to nuanced and balanced discussion.

Many people took what was once a criticism of a wider societal issue about how women feel the need to seek approval from their male counterparts just turned into a new way to insult women people deemed to be annoying. In the past few years, the term has been bastardized to refer to annoying women who aren’t traditionally feminine. Instead of saying that non-traditionally feminine girls are weird or strange, the term pick-me has allowed people to criticize women under the guise of feminism. They claim to be poking fun at women who pretend to like sports and video games for male attention, but gauging whether somebody is truly interested in something is not an exact science. This leaves many women who have traditionally masculine interests being caught in the crossfire and accused of being a pick-me simply because people found a way to arbitrarily criticize women in a socially acceptable way.

The girl who equates femininity to low intelligence and rejects aspects of girlhood to seem more appealing to men absolutely has to work on herself and her outlook on other girls. Being different from one’s idea of what they think most girls are like isn’t inherently a good or bad thing. The only time it becomes an issue is when a woman takes her level of femininity as an indicator of her worth and value.

Though the term pick-me is relatively new, the idea of women who feel they only exist in tandem to men has existed for a long time. Gillian Flynn’s 2012 novel Gone Girl explores this idea in the famous “Cool Girl” monologue. The protagonist, Amy Dunne, has faked her death and framed her husband for her murder as a form of revenge for his infidelity and to regain a sense of agency over her life. Throughout her monologue, Amy focuses her criticism on how men are allowed to control women’s lifestyles without even realizing it. Though she comes from a personal place of resentment for how her husband made her feel inauthentic around him, her overall sentiment resonated with a lot of women. The want to be considered cool while remaining desirable is an exhausting balancing act that many women feel pressured to put themselves through. At times, it comes at the expense of other women and their own sense of self.

Pick-me girl discussions are so redundant and hypercritical of an overall nonissue. People can go on forever about how the nuanced behavior of women is right or not, while men don’t even have to think twice about how their attitudes affect the livelihoods of the women in their lives.

Leave a Reply